Esembly Pail Deodorant vs. Refills: Which Keeps Your Diaper Pail Fresher Longer?

Quick Answer

For most families, the Esembly Diaper Pail Bundle offers the best value: it includes a Pail Pouch and Pail Deodorant at a price lower than buying them separately. If you already have a pail pouch and just need to refresh your odor control, buying the Pail Deodorant on its own is the more economical choice. Both options use the same baking soda-based deodorant, so freshness duration is identical.

Keeping your diaper pail from smelling like a science experiment is a top priority for any cloth diaper parent. Esembly’s Pail Deodorant is a simple, natural solution, but you might wonder whether to grab the Diaper Pail Bundle or just a refill. We’re comparing the two so you can decide which keeps your pail fresher longer—and which is easier on your wallet.

Both options rely on the same deodorizing power, so the real difference comes down to what you already own and how you like to stock up. Let’s break down the facts.

What’s in the Diaper Pail Bundle?

The Diaper Pail Bundle includes two essentials: one Pail Pouch and one Pail Deodorant. The Pail Pouch is a 23" x 26" waterproof liner made of polyester with a TPU laminate, designed to fit most standard diaper pails. It holds 2-3 days’ worth of diapers, wipes, and accessories—enough for a typical cloth diaper routine between washes.

The Pail Deodorant is made of sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) with essential oils of lemon and grapefruit. It sits in the pail to neutralize odors naturally, without harsh chemicals. The bundle is priced at $20.25, a significant saving compared to buying the items separately.

What About the Pail Deodorant Refill?

The Pail Deodorant is available on its own as a refill, so you can replace it when the scent fades. It’s the same product as the one in the bundle—no difference in formula or effectiveness. The refill is ideal if you already have a pail pouch and just need to refresh your odor control.

Since the deodorant is the active odor-fighting component, the refill alone will keep your pail just as fresh as the bundle. The only thing you miss out on is the liner, which you may already own.

Cost Comparison: Bundle vs. Refill

The Diaper Pail Bundle costs $20.25, while the Pail Deodorant alone costs $6.00. If you need both a liner and deodorant, the bundle is clearly the better deal—buying them separately would cost more. But if you already have a liner, the refill is the budget-friendly way to maintain freshness.

Over time, the refill is the more economical choice for ongoing odor control. You only pay for the deodorant, which is the part that actually neutralizes smells. The liner is a one-time purchase (or a washable item, depending on your routine).

The Trade-Off: Bundle vs. Refill

• Diaper Pail Bundle: Best value if you’re starting fresh or need a new liner. Includes both pouch and deodorant at a bundled price. Choose this if you need a liner and want to save on the initial setup.
• Pail Deodorant Refill: Cheapest way to maintain freshness if you already have a liner. Same deodorant, lower price. Choose this if you just need to refresh your odor control.
• Tossers Liners: Not a direct alternative, but using them can reduce solid waste in the pail, helping your deodorant last longer. Consider pairing with either option to extend freshness.

Product Facts at a Glance

• Diaper Pail Bundle: Includes our best-selling Pail Pouch and Pail Deodorant. 1 Pail Pouch measuring 23" x 26" designed to fit most standard diaper pails. Pouch will hold 2-3 days worth of diapers, wipes and accessories. Made of polyester with a waterproof TPU laminate. 1 Pail Deodorant made of Sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) with essential oils of lemon, grapefruit. This bundle gives you everything you need to start odor control from scratch, saving money compared to buying items separately.
• Tossers: Biodegradable cloth diaper liners give you an ick-free way to discard the solid poop before laundering your cloth diapers. While your baby is on a liquid diet (breastmilk or formula), there is no need for Tossers. Once your baby starts eating 2-3 solid meals per day, Tossers will become your new best friend. Using Tossers with your diaper pail can reduce odor by keeping solid waste out of the pail, making your deodorant last longer.

Which Option Fits You?

Best for

• New cloth diaper families who need a liner and deodorant
• Parents who want the convenience of a complete odor-control setup

Not for

• Parents who already own a pail pouch and only need to restock deodorant
• Budget-conscious shoppers who want to minimize ongoing costs

Whether you choose the Diaper Pail Bundle or just the Pail Deodorant refill, you’re getting the same natural, effective odor control. If you’re new to cloth diapering, the bundle is a smart start. If you’re already set up, the refill keeps your pail fresh without extra cost. Pair with Tossers for even less odor and easier cleanup.